Photo Analysis: Spaceship Or Train Station?
Composition & Framing
What works well:
The composition itself is definitely very strong, especially with all the leading lines/elements → The stairs, railings, escalators, walls, lift-tower, reflections, handrails → almost every line points/converges toward the middle section on the ground floor. Your eyes basically have no choice where to go (the only obvious issue however is that there is nothing that ends up catching your attention in that convergence point, but more on that later).
The general symmetry is also very nice + the architecture and lights give this whole scene/photo a very futuristic look.
Depth is another strong point. We our have immediate foreground with the stairs/railing → middle stair section → lower platform → lift structure → background architecture. It does create a really strong sense of space and a very obvious 3D effect (that being enhanced even further by the tunnel-like architecture).
The small person on the bottom platform helps a lot in terms of communicating scale.
What could be better:
As I mentioned, we do have a lot of very great leading lines → and all of them converge nicely in the middle → the issue is that there is nothing to ‘collect’ all that attention. There is no person standing there, no other leading line maybe picking up that attention and guiding us further etc. This is one of those times where waiting a few more extra minutes on location and looking for someone/something to enter that leading line convergence point would have paid off immensely.
The handrail in the centre is very effective, but because it is so thick and large in the foreground (+ it is also pretty glossy and thus picks up even more attention) it does take up a lot of visual space. Some people may find it slightly overpowering.
The small person helps scale + they add a bit of life to this otherwise ‘empty’ architectural shot yes, but they are almost too small to function as a proper subject → if they had ended up in the leading line convergence spot → that would have been different. (admittedly though, the off centre person does break up the symmetry a bit and gives this slightly more ‘character’ and tension)
Light & Atmosphere
What works well:
The lighting works pretty well because it reinforces the futuristic/modern feeling of the architecture.
The cold artificial light creates a very sterile, almost sci-fi/spaceship atmosphere.
The reflections from the glass surfaces help bounce light around and prevent some darker areas from feeling dead.
There is some nice balance here and there between brighter illuminated areas and darker structure.
What could be better:
Some lights are very bright and slightly overpower parts of the photo, especially around the glass reflections there.
Because the lighting is so even and artificial, emotionally the scene can feel a little cold/detached.
Texture
What works well:
Texture plays a important role here.
The stair textures are pretty great and give the foreground lots of detail.
All the metallic surfaces, rails and wall panels all create an interesting industrial/glossy/sharp feel.
Because the scene is so geometric overall, texture helps prevent it from feeling too flat.
What could be better:
Want to read more?
Subscribe to themagazineforphotographers.com to keep reading this exclusive post.
