Photo Analysis: Chicago Golden Hour
Composition & Framing
What works well:
The composition works because everything funnels toward the vanishing point in the centre/distance → the tracks, the buildings, the light etc. It is all working together pulling you in.
The leading lines are excellent, basically everything, from the train itself to the rails, guides you into the distance and into the sunset. Because the rails are glowing with that golden shine, they almost feel like doubled-up leading lines, super strong visually (meaning they are ‘‘double effective’’).
The train is positioned nicely, just off-center, which balances the scene and stops it from being too rigid + that position gives us more to see of the train itself and it also helps with depth.
The layering of elements: tracks in the foreground, train in the mid-ground, glowing light in the background, gives the image a lot of depth and creates this nice 3D effect.
One, let’s say ‘‘unconventional’’ leading line is actually the fact that we can see the train’s red tail-lights, meaning we can see that the train is actually heading into the sunset/distance, which again pulls you in (almost unconsciously).
What could be better:
The framing is very tight on the buildings. It works to exaggerate the tunnel-like effect, but it also feels a bit cramped.
Because the photo is so centered, it feels very locked-in. Shifting the frame slightly could have created more dynamic tension and a more ‘‘interesting’’ image.
The second train in the distance is cool, however it competes a little for attention (especially with the bright headlights). Either waiting for just one train or having them both more aligned might have worked better.
Light & Atmosphere
What works well:
The light here is obviously the big star here. The golden sunset shining through the canyon of buildings is just incredible, it gives the whole scene a fiery glow and immediately makes the photo stand out.
As touched on before, the way the light hits the rails is very nice, they catch just enough of the reflection to create glowing lines that, again, pull your eye right into the distance.
The train itself is lit in a way that feels natural, not overexposed but still catching enough of the golden light to tie it into the scene.
Again, the buildings on each side frame the sunset, creating that tunnel effect.
What could be better:
The highlights in the sky and at the end of the street are really intense. They do look great for drama, but they are also a bit too blown out, so you lose detail in the sunset and the surrounding area.
A bit of subtle detail or texture in that glowing section would make it easier on the eyes while still keeping all the mood.
The sunset glow is so powerful that it almost overwhelms the sense of distance, meaning —> instead of a gradual fade into depth, you sort of get a hard wall of light, which flattens the atmosphere.
Colour & Tone
What works well:
The warm tones of the sunset are definitely nice. They dominate and set the mood.
The contrast between the fiery orange light and the cooler metallic tones of the train and the surrounding buildings etc. works great too + it makes the subject stand out.
The details and shine on the train itself are really nice, and the metallic textures come out beautifully.
What could be better:
Want to read more?
Subscribe to themagazineforphotographers.com to keep reading this exclusive post.
